patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

SPEAK OUT: What’s Better: Main Street or Shopping Malls?

A national expert says malls are out, downtowns are in. Do you agree?

 

It’s a tension being played out across the Baltimore/D.C. region: Are customers spending their money more at shopping malls or in downtown retail districts?

There are some indications that downtown retail districts may be on their way to winning the battle for shoppers.

Richard Florida, a national expert on cities and development, wrote recently on an Atlantic Cities blog post that, “After years of neglect, decline, and abandonment, downtowns across the United States are poised to come back—and not just as redoubts for hipsters, artisanal food, indie music, and trendy boutiques, but as major shopping destinations.” 

Florida pointed to examples of downtown entertainment districts, such as the D.C. corridor that includes Gallery Place Mall and Verizon Center, that have become “entertainment machines,” while high-end shopping at malls, a trend that started in the 70s, is starting to wane.

“The signs of a great reversal are beginning to be seen today, as high-end shopping starts to shift back downtown,” Florida wrote.

Examples of an apparent shift can be observed here as well.

Ellicott City, Sykesville, Reisterstown, Catonsville, Westminster and Arbutus are among the communities in Maryland that have made efforts in recent years to inject life into their downtowns.

In Ellicott City,  business owners have come together to create a variety of "themed" days to draw customers to the historic downtown district. Some served free champagne to women at a recent Girls Night Out event. On the second Sunday of each month, there is a farmers’ market. There are other activities going on downtown, as well.

Meanwhile, indoor shopping malls, such as the soon-to-be demolished Laurel Mall and Owings Mills mall, have struggled and will be undergoing major changes in the coming years in favor of “open-air” shopping centers, as opposed to enclosed structures with shops.

The Mall in Columbia also is going through a redevelopment process to add outdoor space, though the mostly enclosed indoor retail center built in 1971 has been successful and attracts 18 million shoppers a year.

Weigh in below or in our poll. Are shopping malls a relic of the 70s and 80s? Do you prefer shopping in an outdoor, Main Street-type retail district?

  • Where would you rather shop, downtown or at a shopping mall?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Downtown. I like supporting local businesses, and I enjoy the rebirth our downtowns have experienced.
        27 (27%)
    • The mall. I can get everything I need there, from high-end to bargain items.
        16 (16%)
    • A mix. I shop at a variety of places.
        52 (53%)
    • Unsure/other
        2 (2%)
    Total votes: 97
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Main Street, Maryland retail, and Owings Mills Redevelopment

Patch_comments_icon

Lisa Rossi

3:34 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012

It's a mixed bag for me, although I will say this: My husband hates malls. He says he gets "Mall-legs," meaning he doesn't like to walk, or really, even exist, in the mall. I've always thought the Mall in Columbia was beautiful, and I love the carousel, but that's just me. http://columbia.patch.com/articles/top-10-things-i-m-thankful-for-in-columbia

Reply

Amy McGovern

3:40 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012

Ellicott City Rocks! It makes me sad that I have to drive over there and spend money when we have Sykesville Main Street right here! Never understood why our Main Street was not more like E City. We have the same feel and parking here is better. We also have the railroad! What is their secret to a good feel and successful street?

Reply
Comment_arrow

John Fitzgerald

11:52 am on Saturday, June 9, 2012

The problem we face here in Sykesville is that we dont have the retail space available. All of the main street level storefronts are occupied. The problem for the retail environment is we have 26 storefront spaces and only 10 are retail. The rest are service types of businesses. We have beauty shops, 2 insurance companies, a pilates studio, a mortgage company, physical therapy, print shop, 2 grapics design companies. All of the the service businesses for the most part do not bring retail customers to main street. Before the retail draw can happen the balance of retail vs service businesses needs to shift. I am a retail business on main street. Main street trading emporium. Stop in and say hello sometime.

Patch_comments_icon

Lisa Rossi

3:48 pm on Thursday, June 7, 2012

Yes, Amy, I am constantly curious to learn more about Ellicott City's Main Street. The streets there are often filled, and it's especially fun at night when there are street musicians.

Reply

richardzleeson

4:35 am on Friday, June 8, 2012

Coupons may keep you in the store longer. It's a well known fact that the more time you spend in a store, the more money you're likely to spend in that store but if you are focused and follow instructions on "Printaponss" you will save money

Reply

Tracy Smith

8:27 am on Friday, June 8, 2012

I would honestly never go in a mall if I had a choice. The busy malls, like Arundel Mills are down right claustrophobic and overwhelming. I would much rather support local main street businesses. Unfortunately, in many cases, they can not accomodate me. Their hours are very limited and very often there is just not enough selection for basic needs items (housewares; clothing; etc). I do try to utilize local businesses whenever possible, and encourage/ talk them up to all.

Reply

David J Iacono

8:28 am on Friday, June 8, 2012

Malls are the cathedrals of the 20th century. Shopping locally on Main Street is the way to go. You get that good old personal attention and you support local, small businesses that keeps the money in the community. Unfortunately, online shopping may eventually replace both.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Lisa Rossi

9:07 am on Friday, June 8, 2012

Well, now, I should have added online shopping to the poll and story. Why didn't I think of that? Thanks, David, that's a an obvious layer to all of this that should definitely be explored.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chuck Burton

12:39 pm on Friday, June 8, 2012

Yes, the advantage of shopping on-line is that you usually have a specific item or items in mind, and you buy same without becoming attracted to something else and spending more than you planned.

Buck Harmon

9:55 am on Friday, June 8, 2012

Malls are derived for the most part of greed driven corporations...nationwide chain stores.
Lots of corporate overhead also associated with malls...makes it tough for most to receive a fair dollar value.
Private shop owners survive off of local patrons and have to offer the best dollar value in order to compete with the greed driven corporate giants. That's why you see the Main St. atmosphere being created....it works... Hunt Valley...

Reply

Chuck Burton

12:53 pm on Friday, June 8, 2012

The advantage of the Solo property is that is large enough to become a substantial shopping area with quite a few large and small stores, and it is conveniently located where it is quite visible. That is why I suggested elsewhere that GG might talk to JCP about moving there from the Mall, to bring in retail of a higher level than Walmart or Target. The Mall is essentially dead as a shopping destination, and no redevelopment will bring it back beyond people satisfying an early curiosity, the forgetting it again.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Danna Walker

3:00 pm on Friday, June 8, 2012

It seems the day of the mall and unlimited free parking is passing. No one has time to wander around a mall anymore. I like the idea of returning to bustling shopping districts but what to do with our cars?

Reply

kathy gambrill

6:57 pm on Friday, June 8, 2012

I buy clothing at the big stores but shop Main street for unique gifts, books, resturants and services. When you shop Main Street, you get personalized service, the owner is typically the person helping you and more than likely a resident of the community. I much prefer Main Street. Even if you just walk down the street, you usually see people you know. A much better choice.

Reply

Zoobie

12:51 am on Saturday, June 9, 2012

Having been one of the craftspersons that helped build Owings Mills Mall, it's hard to believe it's coming down already. Of course, back-in-the-day, we called it The Guchie Mall, with all the big Noo Yawk retailers there when it first opened. Seems they didn't last long (Not too many could afford to shop them). Well, I guess it's progress in reverse. When I was a kid, my parents travelled to downtown Baltimore to Stewarts, Hoschilds, Hamburgers and all of the Big retailers that helped make Baltimore a great place to shop.(Sometime we even walked to downtown, what a novelty!) Then someone got the bright idea to build 'Eastpoint', and that was the beginning of the end for Baltimore City shopping. More people had cars in the 'fifties', and suburban malls became the rage by the 'sixties'. Everything under one roof, what a novel idea. So, here we go again, back to "Downtown Malls", I think not! We'll never see Macy's or Pennys on our crowded Main Streets. No room, and property values are too high for that concept to win out again. Trust me, the Malls are not dead, just going through another transformation, and who knows what the new versions will behold? Yes, History does repeat itself.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chuck Burton

1:24 pm on Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Remember the beautiful Christmas windows, especially in Hechts and Hoschilds. And the decorations on Howard St. They attracted people (customers) from all around town. There seems to be nothing like that now.

Leave a comment